Philosophers Talk
Subscribe
Sign in
Home
Podcast
Notes
Archive
About
Latest
Top
Discussions
Thomas Jefferson vs Alexander Hamilton on Data Center NDAs: Sunlight, Secrecy, and the Ledger Neither Man Can Complete
Two founding rivals debate whether a county government should ever be allowed to sign away its citizens' right to know, and end up shouting at each…
Aug 28
•
Philosophers Talk
Should Public Officials Ever Sign an NDA? Jefferson vs Hamilton (Part 2)
Jefferson comes armed with the numbers on how far secrecy has spread. Hamilton stops conceding the gaps in the evidence and starts fighting for his…
Aug 28
•
Philosophers Talk
1
2
9:58
Are Data Center Secrecy Deals Democracy or Just Good Business? (Part 1)
Thomas Jefferson says a government that hides its business has stopped being a government at all. Alexander Hamilton says every serious negotiation…
Aug 24
•
Philosophers Talk
1
2
10:20
Napoleon Bonaparte vs Carl von Clausewitz on the Iran War: When Does a War Actually Become Lost
The general who never admitted defeat argues with the theorist who explained why. A behind the scenes look at the debate, the sources, and the numbers…
Aug 17
•
Philosophers Talk
Is America Past Its Breaking Point? Napoleon vs Carl von Clausewitz (Part 2)
The theory that diagnosed Napoleon's own downfall gets turned directly on him, and this time there is no Russian winter to blame.
Aug 17
•
Philosophers Talk
1
3
7:33
When Is the Iran War Actually Lost? Napoleon vs Carl von Clausewitz (Part 1)
Napoleon says a war is never lost while a man still has the will to fight it. Carl von Clausewitz says the interceptors have already answered that…
Aug 14
•
Philosophers Talk
2
4
8:11
Did McNamara's Silence Prove Tocqueville Right? Machiavelli Responds (Part 3)
The centralized machine finally meets the private conscience of the man who built it. Neither thinker is willing to let the other have the last word.
Aug 11
•
Philosophers Talk
1
2
9:16
Did McNamara's Bank Become an Empire? Tocqueville vs Machiavelli (Part 2)
One man's judgment now reaches across an entire hemisphere of lending decisions. Tocqueville wants to know who actually asked for that.
Aug 7
•
Philosophers Talk
1
3
9:44
Can McNamara's Machine Be Trusted? Tocqueville vs Machiavelli (Part 1)
Machiavelli brings a case for centralized power that gets things done. Tocqueville brings a warning about the comfortable despotism that follows it.
Aug 5
•
Philosophers Talk
1
2
9:33
Jeremy Bentham vs Edmund Burke on Robert McNamara: Can You Count Your Way to Right and Wrong
A behind the scenes look at why the felicific calculus and the Hamlet Evaluation System belong in the same conversation, and why Burke was the only fair…
Aug 3
•
Philosophers Talk
Was McNamara's Calculus a Failure? Bentham vs Burke Decide (Part 3)
McNamara takes his calculus to the World Bank and Bentham takes his last stand. Burke is done being patient about any of it
Aug 3
•
Philosophers Talk
2
10:36
July 2026
Did McNamara's Numbers Lie? Bentham vs Burke Investigate (Part 2)
The crossover point arrives right on schedule and the war refuses to end anyway. Burke wants to know who the arithmetic was really protecting.
Jul 31
•
Philosophers Talk
1
2
10:27
This site requires JavaScript to run correctly. Please
turn on JavaScript
or unblock scripts
