Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Did the Iran War Just Cost Trump Congress? Napoleon vs Wellington (Part 1)

Napoleon says the military ledger is a masterpiece and the voters just got cold feet. Wellington says a victory nobody can hold onto is only a very expensive loan.

Duke of Wellington: The President says part of it was Iran. His Vice President says the reason they lost is the war. Even the losing side cannot agree on why it lost.

Napoleon: Every defeat has a thousand explanations, Duke, and I have personally used all of them.

Duke of Wellington: You destroyed their navy and their air force, and you still lost Kansas.

Napoleon: Kansas is not a military objective, Duke. Kansas is a feeling.

Duke of Wellington: This conversation is brought to you by PhilosophersTalk.com, where thinkers discuss!

Napoleon: Created by AITalkerApp.com, create your own animated conversations. Link in the description!

Samuel Johnson: Good evening, and welcome to ringside. I am Samuel Johnson, author of the Dictionary, and I will call tonight’s bout with perfect impartiality. One fighter is a Frenchman, the other was born in Dublin, and the war belongs to the Americans, and as Boswell will tell you, I am willing to love all mankind except an American.

Niccolo Machiavelli: And I am Niccolo Machiavelli, your color man. After the last bout I offered the Emperor my services as an advisor. He asked whether I had ever won anything. I told him no, but that I had written about winning more beautifully than anyone alive.

Samuel Johnson: The tale of the tape, sir. Fifth meeting between these men on the Iran war. In the blue corner, Napoleon, five foot two in French inches, five foot seven in English ones. In the red corner, the Duke of Wellington, holder of the Waterloo belt since 1815, who never lost a battle and never once smiled about it.

Niccolo Machiavelli: And on Tuesday the American voters handed the Democrats both houses of Congress, flipping Senate seats in Kansas, Texas, and Ohio. The President says part of it was Iran. His Vice President says the war was the reason. When the prince and his heir disagree in public about a defeat, I start polishing my resume.

Samuel Johnson: The question in the main event. After nine months, is this war a success or a failure? Napoleon, Duke of Wellington, the floor is yours.

Napoleon: Thank you, Doctor. I watched the American results very closely on Tuesday, which is easy when you are dead, because there is nothing else on the calendar. And I thought, how sad, a great leader betrayed by his own legislature. Then I remembered the exact same thing happened to me in June of 1815, and I felt much better, because it means the President is in very good company.

Duke of Wellington: You were in Belgium in June of 1815. I recall the company very clearly.

Napoleon: Ha, you see, he does jokes now. Very good, Duke. But somebody must make the case for success, so look at the ledger. The supreme leader of Iran was killed in the opening strikes. The President says their navy is gone, their air force is gone, their air defenses are gone. Since July the blockade has turned back one hundred forty four ships. Iran is sending negotiators to Qatar to discuss terms. In my day, when the enemy sends a man to discuss terms, you have won, and everything after that is paperwork.

Duke of Wellington: In your day the enemy was supposed to send a man to discuss terms in Moscow. You waited five weeks for him, and then you walked home.

Napoleon: Moscow was a weather problem, Duke, not a strategy problem. Everybody knows this.

Duke of Wellington: Allow me to state your case better than you did, so nobody can say I beat a weaker version of it. You hold that the war was meant to break Iran’s capacity to threaten its neighbors and to keep a bomb out of its hands. The old supreme leader is dead, the military is shattered, the economy is strangled, and an election is a domestic inconvenience with no bearing on the military facts. Battles are not decided in Kansas. It is not a stupid case. I state it fairly only so that it will lie still while I take it apart.

Napoleon: That is very generous, Duke. I feel like a pheasant being complimented on its feathers by the man holding the gun.

Duke of Wellington: Now the facts. The objective was the nuclear program. In May the atomic energy agency reported that Iran held about four hundred forty kilograms of uranium enriched to sixty percent. No inspector has been inside Iran since February. Nobody in Washington can tell you where that material is tonight. The old supreme leader has been replaced by his son, who has not appeared in public since, and who ordered last week that Iran answer any threat without geographic limits. You removed a man who had issued a religious ruling against the bomb, and you replaced him with a man who has a grievance.

Napoleon: This is the problem with the British. You walk into a room where the furniture is on fire and complain that the curtains are an ugly color.

Duke of Wellington: The curtains are the Strait of Hormuz. Iran’s Revolutionary Guard says four tankers struck mines this week and are still burning. Oil hit one hundred sixteen dollars a barrel in late October and fell below one hundred only on Wednesday, when traders decided the election might end the war. That is a remarkable compliment to pay the voters and a remarkable insult to pay the generals.

Napoleon: Now I will steelman you, though I am only doing it to find the weak beam before I bring down the roof. Your case is that war is a political instrument, and an instrument that cannot reach its political purpose has failed, no matter how much it breaks. The bomb material is missing, the strait is contested, the new leader is harder than the old one, and the American people have now fired the President’s party over it. A victory the voters reject is not a victory, it is a loan, and the interest came due on Tuesday. Do I have it?

Duke of Wellington: You have it exactly. I find that slightly alarming.

Napoleon: Good. It is wrong. In 1806 I closed the whole continent of Europe to British trade, every port from Hamburg to Naples. And for years everybody told me, Napoleon, the prices are high, the people of Bordeaux cannot get their coffee. And I said yes, but the British are suffering more. And they were! Riots! Bank failures! And then I invaded Russia, which is a separate story I do not wish to tell tonight.

Duke of Wellington: It is the only part of the story with an ending.

Napoleon: You see, he waits, he waits, and then he does that. But my point stands. Pressure costs the man who applies it, and that is how you know it is working. The President told Fox News he does not think it was the war, he thinks it was the gasoline price. That is a man who knows the difference between a strategy and its bill.

Duke of Wellington: The gasoline price is the war. The strait is closed because there is a war. That is like a fellow who says he does not mind the battle, it is only the cannonballs that bother him.

Napoleon: The cannonballs are a very small part of a battle, Duke. Mostly it is standing around.

Duke of Wellington: Then let us count the standing around. Eleven Americans killed in combat and twelve more dead from other causes, with more than eight hundred fifty wounded. Two hundred seventy four structures damaged at twenty four American bases. Forty seven billion dollars by October. In September the President said the war would end immediately after the midterm elections. The midterm elections have occurred. The war has not.

Napoleon: He did not say which midterm elections, Duke. There will be others.

Duke of Wellington: Seventy four percent of voters in a Fox News survey called the war a crucial or major factor in their vote. Most voters in the exit polls called it the wrong decision, including about a quarter of Republicans. You cannot fight a long war against a nation’s patience, and you certainly cannot fight one against its gasoline.

Napoleon: You keep saying voters as if it settles something. When I came back from Elba, the people cheered me all the way to Paris. The regiment sent to arrest me joined me instead. One hundred days later the same people asked me to leave. Nothing about my strategy changed in between. The only thing that changed was Belgium.

Duke of Wellington: I was rather involved in Belgium, as it happens.

Napoleon: I know, Duke. You have mentioned it at every dinner party for two hundred years.

Duke of Wellington: Then let me mention something else. After Waterloo I wrote that nothing except a battle lost can be half so melancholy as a battle won. Winning the fighting is the beginning of the work. In Spain the opposition in Parliament wanted me out of the Peninsula for years. I did not answer them with speeches. I answered them with results they could count. This President has given his opponents nothing they can count except the price at the pump. That is why he lost Kansas. That is why he lost Texas. That is why a Senate seat in Maine one woman held for nearly thirty years is gone.

Napoleon: And there you are, Duke, what you always were, an accountant in a red coat. You would have the President fight a war that pleases Kansas. No war has ever pleased Kansas! Kansas does not want to be pleased! The voters did not fire him because of the war. They fired him because the war is not finished, and an unfinished war is the most expensive kind. The cure is not to stop. The cure is to finish it!

Duke of Wellington: Finish what? Name the objective. The memorandum signed in June was a finish, and the President declared it over on the eighth of July. The blockade was lifted, then reimposed. Unconditional surrender was demanded in March, and a ceasefire was taken in April. A war with this many finishes is not a war. It is a farewell tour.

Napoleon: A FAREWELL TOUR? YOU OPPOSED EVERY REFORM IN ENGLAND FOR THIRTY YEARS! YOUR WHOLE CAREER WAS A FAREWELL TOUR FOR THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY!

Duke of Wellington: AND YOUR WHOLE CAREER ENDED ON A ROCK IN THE SOUTH ATLANTIC!

Napoleon: THE BRITISH PUT ME ON THAT ROCK! YOU PUT ME ON THAT ROCK!

Duke of Wellington: YOUR OWN CHAMBER OF REPRESENTATIVES DEMANDED YOUR ABDICATION FIRST!

Napoleon: TACTICALLY THIS WAR IS A MASTERPIECE!

Duke of Wellington: STRATEGICALLY IT IS A BURNING TANKER!

Napoleon: THE NAVY IS GONE!

Duke of Wellington: SO IS THE SENATE!

Napoleon: ACCOUNTANT!

Duke of Wellington: ARSONIST!

Napoleon: SHOPKEEPER!

Duke of Wellington: CORSICAN!

Napoleon: Ahem. Please like and subscribe, if only to watch the Duke lose more slowly in part two. He needs the attention. He has not been this excited since 1829, when a man challenged him to a duel and he missed.

Duke of Wellington: And ring the bell, so you are notified the next time Napoleon blames the weather, the Prussians, Grouchy, or Belgium. He has a rotation.

Napoleon: The Duke of Wellington, everyone, who won the greatest battle of his age and then spent thirty years in politics making everyone wish he had lost it. Doctor Johnson, Signor Machiavelli, back to you in the booth.

Samuel Johnson: What a round, sir! The Duke came out with the casualty count and the uranium nobody can find, and the Emperor answered that Moscow was a weather problem. Boswell, I have never heard a worse excuse delivered with a straighter face.

Niccolo Machiavelli: You missed the real move, Doctor. The Emperor stated the Duke’s case perfectly, said it is wrong, and simply kept walking. Never apologize, never explain, never hand over the belt. Cesare Borgia would have hired him.

Samuel Johnson: On my card, round one to the Duke of Wellington, on points and on uranium.

Niccolo Machiavelli: On mine, round one to the Emperor, because he lost the argument and nobody in the building can tell. Part two is next, when the question becomes what to do now.

Samuel Johnson: I am Samuel Johnson. Somebody fetch Boswell, and somebody fetch the Emperor a map of Kansas.

Niccolo Machiavelli: And I am Niccolo Machiavelli, still accepting offers of employment.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?