Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Strike Now or Make the Deal? Napoleon vs Wellington on Iran's Endgame (Part 2)

Napoleon wants to use the last eight weeks before January to hit the mountain. Wellington has the receipts from Frankfurt, and he is done being polite.

Napoleon: The new Congress is not sworn in until January. That gives us eight weeks, and I once took Vienna in less.

Duke of Wellington: You want to widen a war in the eight weeks before the people who pay for it arrive.

Napoleon: I want to finish an old war, Duke, which is a completely different hobby.

Duke of Wellington: Every man who ever said finish was standing in front of a much bigger war.

Napoleon: This conversation is brought to you by PhilosophersTalk.com, where thinkers discuss!

Duke of Wellington: Created by AITalkerApp.com, create your own animated conversations. Link in the description!

Samuel Johnson: Welcome back to ringside for part two. Round one went to the Duke on my card, and to the Emperor on the card of my colleague, who scores by a different moral system, which is to say none at all.

Niccolo Machiavelli: I score by results, Doctor, which is the only moral system that has never lost an election.

Samuel Johnson: The tale of the tape for round two. What should America do now? Qatar is circulating a draft that opens with three days of confidence building steps. Iran says it could reopen the Strait of Hormuz within two days if its demands are met, including an end to the blockade, its money unfrozen, oil sanctions waived, and the fighting in Lebanon stopped. Meanwhile the President says America is locked and loaded.

Niccolo Machiavelli: And there is a clock in the ring, Doctor. The new Congress takes its seats on the third of January, and Senator Schumer is already talking about the power of the purse. My book advises a prince to commit all his cruelties at once. I suspect the Emperor has read that chapter, because I enclosed it with my job application.

Samuel Johnson: I once wrote an entire pamphlet against Americans complaining about taxation, so I will score the power of the purse with deep suspicion. Napoleon, Duke of Wellington, come out fighting.

Napoleon: Thank you, Doctor. I begin with a confession, which I rarely do, because it is bad for the posture. In 1799 I had a problem with a legislature called the Council of Five Hundred. So I walked into their chamber with some grenadiers, and a good number of the council left through the windows. I am not recommending this. I am only saying it was quick, and a man remembers these things when someone tells him a new Congress arrives in January.

Duke of Wellington: The audience will note that his opening statement was a coup.

Napoleon: A very small coup, Duke. Mostly windows. Now, my proposal. Until January the President still commands the purse and the bombers, and Iran knows it. Their new supreme leader says anyone expecting a shift in American policy after the election is seriously mistaken. Their chief negotiator says Americans said no to war and Iran endorses the message. They are campaigning in your election, Duke! So give them the strike the Israelis have been asking for. Hit Pickaxe Mountain, the nuclear site the President named on Monday. Keep the blockade. Short and intense, which is reportedly what the Gulf allies were told to expect. Then go to Qatar with the rubble on the table. In my experience, the other side becomes very reasonable once the thing they were negotiating about is on fire.

Duke of Wellington: I shall state your case at full strength, since you stated it at full volume. Leverage is perishable. The President holds the purse and the bombers today and may not in January. Iran is openly waiting out the clock, and every week of talks without force is a week Tehran spends rebuilding and betting on Congress. So strike while a strike can still be ordered and paid for, and negotiate from the wreckage rather than the calendar. It is coherent. It is the logic of a man who never once had to wait for a vote of supply, and I state it fairly only so the audience can watch it fall over on its own.

Napoleon: Duke, my arguments do not fall over. Occasionally they retreat from Russia, but they retreat in good order.

Duke of Wellington: They retreated with a small fraction of the men they started with, and that was the good order. You propose to bomb a nuclear site to settle a nuclear question. On the thirty first of October Iran’s security chief said the leadership has made no new decision on its nuclear doctrine, but that could change if the war resumes. You would be bombing the one thing still holding that door shut. And there is the material, four hundred forty kilograms no inspector has seen since February. You cannot bomb what you cannot find. You can only persuade the people hiding it that they need it more.

Napoleon: Ah, the missing uranium. The Duke loves the missing uranium. It is his favorite thing in the world after the Duke.

Duke of Wellington: I am fond of it because nobody else will admit it exists. The whole art of war is finding out what is on the other side of the hill. We do not know where the material is. American officials believe the new supreme leader was seriously wounded. He has not been seen or heard in public since taking the title, and he issues orders through a Telegram account. We do not know if he is well enough to command or merely well enough to sign. And you would bet the whole strait on reading his mind.

Napoleon: You are describing every war in history, Duke. At Austerlitz I did not know what the Russians would do either. So I gave them the heights they wanted and took the heights back when they were standing on the wrong side of the field. I used uncertainty like a sword. You use it like a sofa.

Duke of Wellington: A sofa. Very good. I have sat through worse from better men.

Napoleon: He liked it, you see, he liked the sofa. Now I must steelman your plan, Duke, slowly and carefully, the way one handles a cake that one is about to sit on. You say take the Qatari draft, three days of small steps, because both sides must prove they can keep a little promise before anyone makes a large one. Iran claims it can reopen the strait in two days, so make it prove that first. Congress is not an obstacle but a fact, and a war the purse will not fund in January is a war you should end on your own terms in December. And all of it must be enforced, because the June memorandum was signed and lasted three weeks. It is the plan of a man who would negotiate a truce with a thunderstorm if it promised to rain on schedule.

Duke of Wellington: The thunderstorm would keep its terms better than your Continental System did. The order is everything. The strait and the mines first, verified by ships actually moving. Then inspectors back inside Iran for a full accounting of that uranium. Only then does the blockade lift, in stages. The frozen money goes into an account Iran can see but cannot spend until the material has left the country. And Lebanon goes in a separate room, because if you put every war in the region into one treaty, you will sign nothing before you are dead. After 1815 I commanded the Army of Occupation in France. We stayed until the indemnity was being paid, and then we left two years early, because the occupation had done its work. That is enforcement. Enforcement is not a social media post announcing that the deal is over.

Napoleon: And who pays for your enforcement, Duke? Your new Congress? Senator Schumer is suggesting he may pull the money. Representative Crow calls appropriations one of their most powerful tools. You want to negotiate with Tehran while the people behind you carry the furniture out of the house!

Duke of Wellington: Which is exactly why the deal must be made with Congress and not around it. I fought in Spain for six years under a Parliament that could have cut me off any session it liked. I learned to send home results the opposition could not stand up and deny. Lift the blockade in exchange for tankers moving through Hormuz, and the price of petrol falls, and no Democrat in America will vote against cheaper petrol. That is how you make the purse your ally. You do not race it to January.

Napoleon: You always make it sound so reasonable. Yet in November of 1830, as Prime Minister, you told the House of Lords that the British system of representation was so perfect no reform could improve it. Two weeks later your government was gone. So when you lecture the President on reading the voters, remember you are the only man in history who lost a government by complimenting the constitution.

Duke of Wellington: I did lose it, so I know what it costs to misread the country, which is more than your President can say. On Tuesday night he said he would have done nothing different. In 1829 I told the Lords that to avoid even one month of civil war in Ireland I would sacrifice my life, and I reversed my whole position on Catholic emancipation to prevent it. That is what a man does when the country tells him he is wrong. He changes course and pays the price himself. He does not say it was the gasoline.

Napoleon: You changed course and then fought a duel over it. That is not a change of course, Duke. That is a man who cannot choose between peace and war, so he does both before breakfast.

Duke of Wellington: And you would choose by bombing a mountain eight weeks before your paymaster changes, then demand that the people you bombed reopen a strait they can mine faster than you can sweep it. If the strike misses the uranium, you have a wider war, a Congress that will not fund it, and a supreme leader who has just been proven right. If it succeeds, you have the same uranium question with a larger crater on top.

Napoleon: IF IT SUCCEEDS, IRAN HAS NOTHING LEFT TO BARGAIN WITH! THAT IS WHAT SUCCESS MEANS! YOU HAVE FORGOTTEN BECAUSE YOU HAVE NOT SEEN IT SINCE BELGIUM!

Duke of Wellington: AT FRANKFURT IN 1813 THE ALLIES OFFERED YOU THE RHINE AND THE ALPS! YOU WANTED MORE! WITHIN SIX MONTHS YOU WERE ON ELBA!

Napoleon: FRANKFURT WAS A TRAP! EVERY OFFER FROM A COALITION IS A TRAP!

Duke of Wellington: EVERY OFFER LOOKS LIKE A TRAP TO A MAN WHO PLANS TO BREAK IT!

Napoleon: TAKE VIENNA!

Duke of Wellington: TAKE THE DEAL!

Napoleon: STRIKE THE MOUNTAIN!

Duke of Wellington: COUNT THE URANIUM!

Napoleon: COWARD!

Duke of Wellington: GAMBLER!

Napoleon: TORY!

Duke of Wellington: TYRANT!

Napoleon: Ahem. Do like and subscribe, my friends. The Duke once lost a government by praising the constitution, and now he is trying to lose a war by praising Qatar.

Duke of Wellington: Yes, please subscribe. It is the only vote Napoleon has ever accepted the result of. And when you make your own animated debate at AITalkerApp.com, do not cast him. He will demand top billing and then blame the lighting.

Napoleon: Make your own animated conversations at AITalkerApp.com, link in the description. If you cast the Duke, set his voice to dull, though the software may struggle to tell the difference. Doctor Johnson, Signor Machiavelli, the booth is yours, and please take the Duke with you.

Samuel Johnson: A tremendous bout, sir! The Emperor opened with a coup, the Duke closed with a duel, and in between nobody found the uranium.

Niccolo Machiavelli: My scorecard, Doctor. The Emperor’s plan is pure Prince. Strike once, strike hard, let fear do the negotiating. The Duke’s plan is pure Wellington, which means it might actually work and nobody will enjoy it.

Samuel Johnson: My card goes to the Duke, sir, for the Frankfurt counter. My Dictionary defines a Tory as one who adheres to the ancient constitution of the state. Tonight the Duke adhered to it with a calculator, and I have never been prouder.

Niccolo Machiavelli: My card goes to the Emperor. The Duke has the better plan, but the Emperor has the better chance of being obeyed. The voters told the President no on Tuesday. The question for January is whether anyone else will.

Samuel Johnson: Two rounds, one split decision, and a war still being fought. I am Samuel Johnson. Boswell, tell me you got all of that.

Niccolo Machiavelli: And I am Niccolo Machiavelli. If either gentleman needs an advisor in January, my letters are always open.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?